Suicides and Suicide Attempts in Emergency Medicine
Abstract
Summary:Objective: In emergency medicine, suicides and attempted suicides represent a major challenge for emergency physicians (EPs) and paramedics, both in terms of psychiatric and somatic treatment. To date no investigations have been performed to determine prevalence rates, method of suicide or attempted suicide, and the problems faced by EPs when treating these patients. This investigation presents a first evaluation of the complete emergency protocols from a major German city focusing on suicide and parasuicide. Methods: A retrospective analysis of all EP protocols from 1995 in the city of Hamburg was performed. All protocols were evaluated with respect to suicide parasuicide and suicidal ideation. Demographic data and information on method of suicide or attempted suicide, severity of illness, and underlying psychiatric disorder were extracted from the protocols. Results: A total of 26,347 emergency protocols were evaluated. Suicide and attempted suicide were considered either certain, probable, or possible in 743 cases (2.8%). Suicide was committed in 171 cases and attempted were made by 572 individuals. More men committed suicide in all age groups. By far the highest number of suicide attempts were by young men between 18 and 39 years of age. Hanging was the most commonly used method of completed suicide (41%), followed by jumping from a height (21%). The methods of intoxication with medication (54%) and illegal drugs (17%) clearly prevailed in suicide attempts. Documentation of suicides and attempted suicides was revealed to be unsatisfactory. Underlying psychiatric disorders were scarcely recorded. Conclusion: In emergency medicine, the incidence of suicide or the attempt to commit suicide is small, yet disturbing. The frequency assessed may be too low as result of methodology. There is a need to improve the education of emergency physicians and paramedics in this area, and there is a need for data to be collected in a prospective design.
References
Predictors of further suicidal behavior of patients hospitalized after attempted suicide.. Fortschritte Neurologie und Psychiatrie, (1985). 53, 259–270
The Ulm Emergency Training Course. 2: Realization and acceptance of the emergency medicine practicum.. Anästhesiologie Intensivmedizin Notfallmedizin Schmerztherapie, (1996). 31, 222–227
Health report for Germany.. Stuttgart: Metzler-Poeschel Verlag (1998).
Kursbuch Rettungsdienst: Curriculum zum Fachkundenachweis “Rettungsdienst” ‘Manual to the emergency physician basic training program’.. Köln: German Medical Association (1994).
Rettungsassistent und Rettungssanitäter (2.ed.) ‘Paramedics’.. Berlin: Springer-Verlag (1989).
Why has suicide increased in young males?. Crisis, (1998). 19, 119–124
Suicide, and other causes of death, following attempted suicide.. British Journal of Psychiatry, (1988). 152, 359–366
Deliberate self-harm patients who leave the accident and emergency department without a psychiatric assessment. A neglected population at risk of suicide.. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, (2001). 50, 87–93
Zur präklinischen Versorgung suizidaler Krisen im Notarztdienst ‘Preclinical care of suicidal crises in emergency medicine’.. Suizidprophylaxe, (1997). 3, 118–124
Interdisciplinary aspects of treating psychiatric emergency situations.. German Interdisciplinary Journal of Emergency Medicine, (1999). 2, 504–511
Frequency of psychiatric emergency situations in the pre-clinical emergency system.. Der Notarzt, (1996). 12, 12–17
Evaluation of suicide risk in emergency service.. Anästhesiologie Intensivmedizin Notfallmedizin Schmerztherapie, (1996). 31, 615–620
Prevalence and risk factors of suicide and attempted suicide.. Encephale, (1994). 20, 495–503
Quality assessment of continuing medical education.. Anästhesist, (1996). 45, 363–371
Methods used for parasuicide: Results from the WHO/EURO multicenter study on parasuicide.. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, (2000). 35, 156–163
Characteristics of young suicide attempters and their importance for helpers.. Psychotherapie, Psychosomatik, Medizinische Psychologie, (1994). 44, 1–6
Emergency medicine in Germany.. Annals of Emergency Medicine, (1998). 31, 111–115
DIVI emergency medicine protocol—Version 4.0, revision.. Anästhesiologie und Intensivmedizin, (2000). 41, 46– 49
The nation-wide emergency medicine protocol. Recommendations of the DIVI.. Intensivmedizin, (1994). 29, 450–455
Emergency medicine in France.. Annals of Emergency Medicine, (1998). 31, 116–120
Psychiatric emergencies in preclinical emergency medical service: Frequency, treatment, and assessment by emergency physicians and paramedics.. Der Nervenarzt, (2001). 72, 685– 692
Psychiatric emergency situations in the German physician based pre-hospital emergency medical system.. Anästhesist, (1998). 47, 588–594
Crisis intervention in suicidal patients—An evaluation of the knowledge of emergency physicians.. Suizidprophylaxe, (2000). 27, 24–30
Pre-clinical psychiatric emergencies in the physician-based emergency system of a German metropolis.. Fortschritte Neurologie und Psychiatrie, (2001). 69, 170–174
Evaluation of a training program “Psychiatry for emergency physicians.”. Anästhesiologie Intensivmedizin Notfallmedizin Schmerztherapie, (2001). 36, 105–109
On-scene helicopter transport of patients with multiple injuries—comparison of a German and an American system.. Journal of Trauma, (1992). 33, 548– 555
Frequencies and trends in attempted suicide in the Federal Republic of Germany—A methodological study.. Das Öffentliche Gesundheitswesen, (1988). 50, 272–277
Epidemiology of suicides and suicide attempts.. Nervenheilkunde, (1996). 15, 496–506
Psychiatric consultation in the general hospital emergency department.. Psychiatric Services, (1995). 46, 555–557
Evaluation of attempted suicides: A comparative study of staff in a general hospital and consulting staff in a psychiatric hospital.. Crisis, (1989). 10, 123–131
Selection of patients who attempted suicide for psychiatric consultation.. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (1991). 83, 179–182
