The influence of protection, palliation and costs on mobility optimization of residents in nursing homes: A thematic analysis of discourse
Introduction
With the aging of the global population and increasing numbers of older people living in nursing homes,1 quality of care is a concern. In Australia standards set for nursing homes require that residents’ mobility be optimized through rehabilitation or maintenance therapy (Commonwealth of Australia, 2008a). There is evidence demonstrating the benefits of rehabilitation, functional training and physical activity on the mobility of older people in nursing homes (Forster et al., 2009, Rydwick et al., 2004, Weening-Dijksterhuis et al., 2011). As residents are often dependent on staff assistance to perform functional tasks, staff efforts should be made to restore resident mobility where possible or to otherwise maintain or slow rates of deterioration of mobility.
Current rhetoric (persuasive language or discourse) expects that nursing home environments be safe and comfortable, meet regulatory requirements and be consistent with resident care needs (Care Quality Commission, 2011, Commonwealth of Australia, 2008a). This requires that approaches to resident care accommodate residents’ mobility needs and outcomes. However, goal based tensions (e.g. safety versus resident mobility optimization) can exist when residents require staff assistance to move. The issue is one of risk management, where the risk of resident or staff injury is considered against the risks associated with constrained approaches to resident mobility optimization. Few studies have investigated the impact of care approaches on resident mobility outcomes. A systematic review (Taylor et al., 2011) found only one study that had investigated the impact of safe manual handling approaches on resident mobility and transfer outcomes (Nelson et al., 2008). Given the relative paucity of evidence from randomized trials in this area, it is highly likely that expert opinion has strongly influenced the development of policy and evolution of practice in this field. Such expert opinion falls within the domain of health care discourse.
Ingalill Hallberg (2009), President of the European Academy of Nursing Science, suggests that research should be located within health care discourse. However the existence and power of discourse may not be well understood. Discourses may appear as what is taken for granted, felt to be right or possibly as the persuasion or authority of others such as peers, supervisors, managers, experts or professional bodies. The aim of this study therefore was to uncover and establish the influence of discourses connected to optimizing resident mobility so that the origins and reasoning behind existing and intersecting policy and practice can be critically appraised.
Section snippets
Discourse defined
The term discourse can refer to “language-in-use” (talk and text) as well as a broader use of the word where combinations of thoughts, words, objects, events, actions and interactions create meaning; in other words, the socio-cultural context of the “language-in-use” (Smith, 2007). Discourse is a dynamic process; dialog and interaction result in constant transformation of meaning (Gee, 2005, Hansen, 2006) therefore texts that referred to relevant actions, events and interactions were considered
Search strategy
In the course of working as a physiotherapist in nursing homes for over 20 years, discourses that impact on resident mobility were evident to the first author (JT). Discourses also emerged from many informal discussions with colleagues. The search strategy for literature on discourses was, therefore, purposive and included searching for relevant discourse analyses as well as recent guidelines or literature reviews on each discourse. A snowballing search strategy was used to find literature
Discussion
A welcome emphasis on safety regarding resident manual handling has emerged in nursing homes as a result of socio-cultural forces, in particular nursing leadership and advocacy. Palliative care and falls prevention, but also restraint prevention, have emerged as important discourses relevant to nursing homes. Whilst these are positive movements, the same socio-cultural forces are ambiguous regarding how safety and quality care concerns and the imperative to optimize resident mobility will be
Conclusion
It is important to examine the intersection of various discourses that relate to resident mobility. The danger for the mobility of residents in nursing homes to be ignored or be seen as an issue of little significance is inherent within each of the discourses presented in this paper. In the current environment, which is sensitive to costs of care, it could be pragmatic to overlook dependency support behavior in nursing homes. Such practice would most likely be unintended, ignored or covert.
Acknowledgements
Assoc. Prof. Haines is supported by a National Health & Medical Research Council Career Development Award.
Janice Taylor is supported by Primary Health Care Research Evaluation & Development Fellowship 2009.
References (66)
- et al.
The evolution of palliative care and the relevance to residential aged care: understanding the past to inform the future
Collegian
(2008) - et al.
Coping strategies of enrolled nurses in nursing homes: shifting between organizational imperatives and residents’ needs
International Journal of Nursing Studies
(1997) Moving and handling – the current policy
Physiotherapy
(1997)Moving nursing research forward towards a stonger impact on health care practice?
International Journal of Nursing Studies
(2009)- et al.
Development and evaluation of a multifaceted ergonomics program to prevent injuries associated with patient handling tasks
International Journal of Nursing Studies
(2006) Interprofessional boundaries between nursing and physiotherapy in the orthopaedic setting
Journal of Orthopaedic Nursing
(1999)- et al.
The driving and retraining forces that prmote and impede the implementation of individualized nursing care: a literature review
International Journal of Nursing Studies
(2009) - et al.
Discourses associated with nursing aged people who are dying in the Australian context: a review of the literature
International Nursing Review
(2008) Being below the horizon: the dwelling place of the nurse aide
International Journal for Human Caring
(2008)- Ashford, M., 2003. Private Aged Care No Lift Project. VAHEC-ANF...
Preventing Falls and Harm fom Falls in Older People: Best Practice Guidelines for Australian Residential Aged Care Facilities
The Aged Care Funding Instrument – removing physiotherapy form the aged and driving funding-focused service
The Many Faces of Dependency in Old Age
Maintenance and rehabilitation of indpendence in old age: an intervention program for staff
Psychology and Aging
Patterns of communication in old age: the dependence-support and independence-ignore script
Health Communication
Decision-Making Tool: Responding to Issues of Restraint in Aged Care
User voice, interprofessionalism and postmodernity
Journal of Interprofessional Care
The meaning of mobility for residents and staff in long-term care facilities
Journal of Advanced Nursing
The relationship between staffing and quality in long-term care facilities: exploring the views of nurse aides
Journal of Nursing Care Quality
Developing community in care homes through a relationship-centred approach
Health & Social Care in the Community
Developing relationships in long term care environments: the contribution of staff
Journal of Clinical Nursing
Interventions for preventing falls in older people in nursing facilities and hospitals
Cochrane Collaboration Library
What Standards to Expect From the Regulation of Your Care Home
At the margins? Discourse analysis and qualitative research
Qualitative Health Research
An evaluation of a best practices musculoskeletal injury prevention program in nursing homes
Injury Prevention
Nurses’ perceptions of physiotherapists as rehabilitation team members
Clinical Rehabilitation
Prioritizing safe patient handling: The American Nurses Association's Handle with Care Campaign
Journal of Nursing Administration
Intrinsic job satisfaction, overall satisfaction, and intention to leave the job among nursing assistants in nursing homes
The Gerontologist
Guidelines for a Palliative Approach in Residential Care
Interprofessional education and teamworking: a view from the education providers
BMJ
Cited by (10)
Gen Z Students Perception of Ideal Learning in Post-Pandemic: A Phenomenological Study From Indonesia
2023, International Journal of Educational MethodologyOlder adults in skilled nursing facilities demonstrate low physical activity during and after discharge
2022, Disability and RehabilitationThematic analysis of qualitative data: AMEE Guide No. 131
2020, Medical TeacherExploring manual handling practices by informal carers
2016, International Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation