Elsevier

Child Abuse & Neglect

Volume 30, Issue 2, February 2006, Pages 157-170
Child Abuse & Neglect

Psychological defense styles, childhood adversities and psychopathology in adulthood

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2005.08.016Get rights and content

Abstract

Objective

The present study explores the link between reported sexual and/or physical abuse and psychological defense styles, as well as the association of both with psychological distress in adulthood. In two patient samples that differ in psychological distress and somatization, we examine whether the adversities reported and immature defense styles are associated with psychopathological symptoms.

Method

We examined 266 consecutive inpatients in the psychosomatic department and 109 consecutive inpatients who had been treated for low-back pain in the orthopedic department of a German university hospital. Psychological defense styles were assessed by a two-factor solution of the German modified adaptation of the Defense Mechanism Inventory (DMI), childhood adversities by a structured interview, psychological distress by the SCL-90-R, and somatization by the Screening for Somatoform Disorders (SOMS).

Results

Both samples demonstrated a significant link between immature defense styles and the extent of overall psychological distress as well as somatization. Reported sexual and/or physical abuse of patients in both patient samples was directly associated with somatization.

Conclusion

Recollections of sexual and/or physical abuse in childhood and immature defense styles have an association with psychopathology in adulthood. This finding suggests that immature defense styles may act, in part, as mediators between the adversities investigated and adult psychopathology.

Résumé

Objectif

La présente étude explore les liens entre les mauvais traitements physiques, sexuels ou psychologiques et les types de défenses psychologiques. On a aussi étudié les liens entre ces deux facteurs et la détresse psychologique en âge adulte. Afin de voir si les adversités relatées et les styles immatures sont reliés à des symptômes psychopathologiques, les auteurs ont étudié deux groupes de patients qui différaient au niveau de leur détresse psychologique et de leur somatisation.

Méthode

Nous avons étudié 266 patients dans un service interne de médecine psychosomatique, et 109 patients consécutifs dans un service interne d’orthopédie d’un hôpital universitaire allemand, lesquels avaient été traités pour une douleur dorsale. On a évalué les types de défense psychologique au moyen du Defense Mechanism Inventory, modifié pour le contexte allemand. On a aussi étudié les adversités en enfance au moyen d’une entrevue structurée, puis la détresse psychologique au moyen du SCL-90-R, et enfin la somatisation au moyen du Screening for Somatoform Disorders.

Résultats

Les deux échantillons démontrent un lien important entre les styles de défense immature et l’ampleur de la détresse psychologique ainsi que de la somatisation. Les mauvais traitements qu’ont dévoilés les patients dans les deux groupes sont reliés directement à la somatisation.

Conclusion

Il existe une association entre les souvenirs de mauvais traitements physiques et/ou sexuels en enfance ainsi que les styles de défense immature et la psychopathologie adulte. Ce constat porte à croire que les styles de défense immature pourraient, en partie, jouer un rôle au niveau des liens entre les adversités en enfance et la psychopathologie en âge adulte.

Resumen

Objetivo

Este estudio explora la relación entre el autoinforme de maltrato físico y/o abuso sexual y los estilos psicológicos de defensa, así como la asociación de ambos con el malestar psicológico en la edad adulta. Se han analizado dos muestras de pacientes que se diferencian en el malestar psicológico y la somatización. En ambas muestras se examina si las adversidades notificadas y lo estilos defensivos inmaduros están asociados con síntomas psicopatológicos.

Método

Se examinan 266 pacientes consecutivos en el departamento de enfermedades psicosomáticas y 109 pacientes con dolores en la zona inferior de la espalda tratados en el departamento de traumatología. Ambos departamentos pertenecen a un hospital universitario alemán. Los estilos psicológicos de defensa fueron examinados a través de la versión adaptada para Alemania del Inventario de Mecanismos de Defensa. Las adversidades infantiles se evaluaron utilizando una entrevista estructurada, el malestar psicológico con el SCL-90-R y la somatización con el Protocolo de Evaluación de Trastornos Somatoformes (SOMS).

Resultados

Ambas muestras demostraron una relación significativa entre los estilos de defensa inmaduros y la existencia de malestar psicológico general y somatización. La existencia de autoinformes de maltrato físico y/o abuso sexual en ambas muestras de pacientes estaba directamente asociada con la somatización.

Conclusiones

La presencia de recuerdos de maltrato físico y/o abuso sexual en la infancia y de estilos de defensa inmaduros están asociados con la presencia de malestar psicológico en la edad adulta. Este hallazgo sugiere que los estilos inmaduros de defensa pueden actuar, en parte, como mediadores entre las adversidades infantiles y la psicopatología en la edad adulta.

Introduction

Previous studies have verified that psychosocial risk factors, especially sexual abuse during childhood and adolescence, increase vulnerability for mental disorders in adulthood (Fergusson, Horwood, & Woodward, 2000; Mullen, Martin, Anderson, Romans, & Herbison, 1996; Werner & Smith, 1992). Child sexual abuse is strongly associated with multiple other forms of adverse childhood experiences (Clemmonsa, DiLillo, Martinez, DeGuea, & Jeffcottc, 2003; Dong, Anda, Dube, Giles, & Felitti, 2003). Indeed, the cumulative effect of psychosocial risk factors during childhood also increases the occurrence of adult adjustment problems (Clemmonsa et al., 2003) as well as frequent somatic diseases, such as heart disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, diabetes, obesity, or sexually transmitted diseases (Felitti et al., 1998). Patients who have experienced abuse are more frequently ill, seek medical help more often (Felitti, 2002), and have a higher incidence of surgery (Kendall-Tackett, Marshall, & Ness, 2000). Women who were treated with outpatient psychotherapy and who reported childhood sexual abuse had significantly more other family background risk factors than comparison groups and an increased risk of posttraumatic stress disorder (Peleikis, Mykletun, & Dahl, 2004).

The mechanisms that lead from childhood adversity to long-term effects in later life have not yet been sufficiently determined. Risk-taking behavior such as substance abuse (Felitti, 2002, Kendall-Tackett et al., 2000, Taussig, 2002) and sexual risk-taking behavior (Fergusson et al., 2000) may play an important role as a developmental path in this context. Additional potential mediating factors are the ability to create and maintain relationships and the quality of current and past social and interpersonal relationships. Recent results support the hypothesis that alexithymia mediates between a history of childhood maltreatment and self-injurious behaviors (Paivio & McCulloch, 2004). Moreover, it has been suggested that adaptive childhood emotional inhibition as a reaction to emotional invalidation is associated with adult psychological distress mediated by a style of inhibiting emotional experience and expression (Krause, Mendelson, & Lynch, 2003). Thus, patients who have experienced sexual and/or physical abuse more frequently report dysfunctional relationships (Becker-Lausen & Mallon-Kraft, 1997). Psychological defense styles are discussed, in particular, as moderators or mediators of early negative relationships and adult psychopathology (Mickelson, Kessler, & Shaver, 1997). Therefore, empirical study of this potentially moderating association of defense styles on adult psychopathology is justified. Tauschke, Helmes, and Merskey (1991) and Tauschke, Merskey, and Helmes (1990) demonstrated a moderate yet significant link between immature defense mechanisms and parental neglect as well as a link between a predominance of more mature defense styles and more empathetic parental behavior. They concluded that the maturity of the defense mechanisms is more strongly determined by childhood experiences and lasting personality traits than by currently perceived anxiety and depression. Other investigators (Flannery & Perry, 1990) also show a close association of immature defense styles with a heightened perception of stress, physical illness, and affective symptoms. An investigation of 490 Chinese adolescents showed immature coping styles to be associated with an increase in general and specific psychopathological symptoms (Chan, 1997).

Vaillant (1998), in the prospective Grant Study, also found a significant link between early childhood experiences and the degree of maturity of defense mechanisms in adulthood. In this study, he examined the lives of a group of Harvard men, 268 members of the classes of 1941 through 1944, who have been studied from their college years all the way to retirement and, in some cases, death. Emotional problems in childhood as well as a poor childhood environment were associated with immature adaptive styles. Moreover, it was apparent that the maturity of an individual's defense mechanisms exerted an influence on morbidity and mortality. However, when conflicts were mastered sufficiently and stable relationships in adulthood had been established, the defense styles matured.

In the present study, we investigate the link between sexual and/or physical abuse during childhood and immature psychological defense styles, as well as the influence of both on somatization and psychological distress in adulthood. To our knowledge the present study is the first that focused on the link between childhood maltreatment, psychological defense styles and adult psychopathology in two different inpatient samples.

We test whether two patient samples differ in terms of the magnitude of their psychological distress and somatization and whether, independent of that, immature defense styles and the childhood adversities have an influence on psychopathology in adulthood. The orthopedic patient sample has been chosen because some investigators reported a higher frequency of childhood adversities in patients with chronic low-back pain (McMahon, Gatchel, Polation, & Mayer, 1997; Nickel, Egle, & Hardt, 2002; Schofferman, Anderson, Hines, Smith, & White, 1992).

We developed three hypotheses: first, we hypothesize that patients from the orthopedic treatment center with chronic low-back pain will have less immature defense styles than patients from the psychosomatic department of the same university hospital who have psychic and psychosomatic disorders. Second, that independent of the patient population investigated, patients with immature defense styles will have a greater magnitude of psychological distress and somatization. Third, that a reported history of childhood sexual and/or physical abuse is associated with immature psychological defense styles in adulthood.

Section snippets

Methods

We included in our study 266 consecutive inpatients from the psychosomatic–psychotherapeutic department and 109 consecutive inpatients, who were treated for chronic low-back pain, from the orthopedic department of the university hospital in Mainz, Germany (Table 1). Patients participated voluntarily and gave informed consent for us to publish the data. The orthopedic patient sample has been described in detail elsewhere (Nickel et al., 2001). From 191 consecutive inpatients, 121 met the

Results

The two patient samples differed on a number of central psychosocial parameters, age and sex distribution, current life situation, and case history of illness (Table 1). In the psychosomatic sample, more patients were female (66% vs. 40.4%, p < .0001); they reported less often a stable relationship (34.9% vs. 62.4%, p < .0001) and were younger (mean 38.6 vs. 43.4, p < .0001) at the time of the investigation as well as at the onset of their complaints (mean 32.3 vs. 38.4, p < .0001). The duration of

Discussion

The present study investigated the associations among childhood maltreatment, maturity of defense styles in adulthood, and psychopathological symptoms in adulthood. An extensive, structured biographical interview assessed the childhood adversities of “sexual abuse” and “physical abuse.”

In the present study we focused on the similarities between two different patient populations with regard to immature psychological defense styles and adult psychopathology. We found that independent of the

References (42)

  • R.C. Albucher et al.

    Defense mechanism changes in successfully treated patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder

    American Journal of Psychiatry

    (1998)
  • E. Becker-Lausen et al.

    Pandemic outcomes: the intimacy variable

  • I.H. Bernstein et al.

    On the utility of the SCL-90-R with low-back pain patients

    Spine

    (1994)
  • D. Chan

    Defensive styles and psychological symptoms among Chinese adolescents in Hong Kong

    Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology

    (1997)
  • J.C. Clemmonsa et al.

    Co-occurring forms of child maltreatment and adult adjustment reported by Latina college students

    Child Abuse & Neglect

    (2003)
  • L. Derogatis

    SCL-90

    (1977)
  • U.T. Egle

    Die biographische Anamnese als diagnostische Grundlage im Rahmen eines bio-psycho-sozialen Schmerzverständnisses

  • U.T. Egle et al.

    Long-term effects of adverse childhood experiences—actual evidence and need for research

    Zeitschrift für Psychosomatische Medizin und Psychotherapie

    (2002)
  • V.J. Felitti

    The relationship of adverse childhood experiences to adult health: Turning gold into lead

    Zeitschrift für Psychosomatische Medizin und Psychotherapie

    (2002)
  • D. Fergusson et al.

    The stability of child abuse reports: a longitudinal study of the reporting behaviour of young adults

    Psychological Medicine

    (2000)
  • Franke, G. (1995). SCL-90-R. Die Symptom-Checkliste von Derogatis - Deutsche Version. Göttingen:...
  • Cited by (44)

    • Predictors of psychological distress following major trauma

      2019, Injury
      Citation Excerpt :

      Furthermore, other variables which were not explored in the study, such as coping self efficacy, anger, and education level have been found to impact on psychopathology following traumatic injury [41]. This is a limitation of the study and further work is required to investigate this in more detail in trauma populations [34,42]. We conclude that the Posttraumatic Adjustment Screen (PAS) has reasonable accuracy in our series and shows promise in objectively identifying patients who might benefit from clinical psychology intervention at an early stage.

    • The connectivity / conversion paradigm - A new approach to the classification of psychosomatic disorders

      2019, New Ideas in Psychology
      Citation Excerpt :

      If this does not succeed, somatic forms of expression of the emotions associated with the aforementioned conflicts serve as a fall-back in the second phase of defence. In this context, the alexithymic recourse to equivalents of affect can be understood as a psychological form of defence (Nickel & Egle, 2006) serving to avoid the negative emotions potentially arising as a result of interpersonal conflicts (Waller & Scheidt, 2006). According to the cognitive behavioural disorder model, somatic symptoms are perceived more strongly and emotionally misjudged in the interaction between distress and the presence of minor physical symptoms (Rief & Broadbent, 2007).

    • Differential effects of childhood trauma subtypes on fatigue and physical functioning in chronic fatigue syndrome

      2017, Comprehensive Psychiatry
      Citation Excerpt :

      These victimized individuals are characterized by less effective psychological defence and coping styles, which may lead to an increased sensitivity for future stressors, unhealthy behaviours and lifestyles, as well as psychiatric problems such as anxiety, depression, and sleep disorders. All these factors may directly or indirectly contribute to a person's fatigue and functional limitations [41,42]. Secondly, childhood trauma has been shown to cause dysfunctions in the human stress system, most notably in the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, which increases a person's vulnerability for a wide variety of psychological and (functional) somatic disorders [5,11,34,43].

    • Predictors of PTSD symptoms in adults admitted to a Level I trauma center: A prospective analysis

      2014, Journal of Anxiety Disorders
      Citation Excerpt :

      However, when controlling for PTSD severity at baseline, only age, number of premorbid psychiatric disorders, and gunshot wounds predicted PTSD symptoms at 3-month follow-up, but with 78.5% accuracy. Our findings are consistent with the existing literature on PTSD predictors suggesting younger age (Alarcon et al., 2012; Chiu et al., 2011), depression (O’Donnell, Creamer, & Pattison, 2004; Shalev et al., 1998), number of premorbid psychiatric disorders (Nickel & Egle, 2006), gunshot wounds/penetrating injuries (Alarcon et al., 2012), auto vs. pedestrian injuries (Alarcon et al., 2012), and alcohol use (McFarlane et al., 2009) are all risk factors for PTSD. However, after controlling for PTSD symptoms at the time of admission, only age, number of premorbid psychiatric disorders, and gunshot wounds remained as significant predictors of later PTSD.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text