Research
A survey of violence toward nursing staff in one large irish accident and emergency department

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0099-1767(97)90010-6Get rights and content

Abstract

Introduction Nurses in Ireland are increasingly concerned about the escalating incidence of verbal and physical abuse, particularly in Accident and Emergency (A&E) Departments. This first detailed survey of violence in A&E departments in Ireland was conducted at St. James's Hospital, Dublin, the largest hospital in the Republic of Ireland. The aims of the survey included determining the following factors: (1) what proportion of staff had experienced physical or verbal violence while on duty in the hospital, (2) the frequency of such attacks, (3) whether the violence was officially reported and sick leave taken, (4) whether age and experience changed attitudes to violence, or the reporting of it, and (5) the level of staff training, if any, in dealing with violence.

Methods A wide-ranging questionnaire was designed and confidentially offered to nurses and attendants (patient care assistants). Standard definitions of physical and verbal violence were framed.

Results Of 36 nurses on staff, 27 responded; nine of 13 attendants responded. Doctors were not included because only one is a permanent, non-contract employee. The responding nurses ranged in experience from newly qualified to senior nurses and unit managers with more than 15 years A&E service. The survey found that half of the nurses had been assaulted physically, or verbally, one third within the past 12 months. Only two of the 27 respondent nurses were not worried about being physically assaulted—both were psychiatric-trained male nurses and neither had ever been assaulted. Most verbal abuse was not reported—despite availability of an official report book—and 29% of nurses had not even reported their last physical assault. The likelihood of reports of verbal violence being made increased with age and experience. Staff criticised hospital managers, the police, and the courts for their attitude about assaults on nurses. Respondents believed assaults on nurses were treated less seriously than similar incidents involving private citizens.

Discussion The results of this study mirrored those of similar surveys in Britain and the United States. Nonreporting was revealed as a major problem, whereas reporting violence was often seen as an empty gesture because of a lack of institutional support for the nurse/attendant victims. Staff reported feeling vulnerable to abuse and there was a general desire for training in self-protection. Since the survey was first presented to hospital managers, St James's Hospital has made a number of changes to improve staff security. These include teaching staff breakaway techniques, increasing the number of security officers on duty, issuing personal alarms, and encouraging staff to officially report all incidents.

References (6)

  • Violence at work in the health service sector

    (Oct 1992)
  • JR Lion et al.

    Under-reporting of assaults on staff in a state hospital

    Hosp Community Psychiatry

    (1981)
  • J Ryan et al.

    Workplace violence

    Nurs Times

    (1993)
There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (65)

  • Workplace violence against nurses in the emergency departments of three hospitals in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: A cross-sectional survey

    2016, NursingPlus Open
    Citation Excerpt :

    In a survey of 300 nurses, only 9.1% had never experienced physical violence. In the largest hospital in Dublin, only 27 nurses (7%) were not worried about physical assault (Rose, 1997). The findings of surveys are similar throughout the world.

  • Nurses' perceptions of the factors which cause violence and aggression in the emergency department: A qualitative study

    2014, International Emergency Nursing
    Citation Excerpt :

    Nurses are more likely than other health care professionals to be involved in aggressive incidents with patients and relatives in the ED. Much of the research undertaken on this topic is quantitative in nature and examines prevalence and prediction of violence (Rose, 1997;Alameddine et al., 2011; Esmaeilpour et al., 2011; Talas et al., 2011; Magnavita and Heponiemi, 2012). However, qualitative exploration of this phenomenon is increasing (Pich et al., 2011; Lau et al., 2012).

  • Violent behaviour from young adults and the parents of paediatric patients in the emergency department

    2013, International Emergency Nursing
    Citation Excerpt :

    The International Council of Nurses has reported that the majority of nurses (72%) globally do not feel safe at work, while a survey of American nurses put this figure at upwards of 80% (ANA, 2001). An Irish study found that 91% of nurses were worried about being physically assaulted while at work (Rose, 1997). This is especially significant when considering that Occupational Health and Safety legislation and guidelines exist in most countries to protect the health, safety and welfare of workers.

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text