Abstract
BACKGROUND
Decisions to limit treatment in critically ill patients often rely on publications that make claims of futility based on outcome data. Our objective was to systematically review the criteria for futility and the strength of empirical evidence across clinical studies that purport to support or refute claims of futility.
METHODS
The MEDLINE database was searched for relevant articles published between1980 and 2008. Selected studies reported original outcome data in critically ill or cardiac arrest patients and claimed that these data can support or refute decisions to limit treatment in comparable patients. Two authors independently abstracted data on patient characteristics, intervention, outcomes, cost, and design.
RESULTS
Forty seven studies supporting a claim of futility and 45 refuting it were reviewed. Median point estimate for adverse outcome in studies supporting claims of futility was 100% (range 75% to 100%); median lower 95% confidence limit was 91% (range 48% to 99%). Explicit thresholds for futility were missing in 88% of articles. The original criteria for quantitative futility were fulfilled by only 28% of data, and almost exclusively in studies of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) for cardiac arrest. Substantial statistical overlap was observed between data brought in support of futility claims and data brought to refute them.
CONCLUSIONS
Most studies that purport to guide determinations of futility are based on insufficient data to provide statistical confidence for clinical decision-making. They usually lack explicit a priori thresholds for determination of futility. Many studies draw disparate conclusions based on statistically similar data. In most circumstances these problems preclude confident determinations of futility.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Zingmond DS WN. Regional and Institutional Variation in the Initiation of Early Do-Not-Resuscitate Order. Arch Intern Med. 2005;165:1705–12.
Hakim RB, Teno JM, Harrell FE Jr, et al. Factors associated with do-not-resuscitate orders: patients' preferences, prognoses, and physicians' judgments. SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatment. Ann Intern Med. 1996;125(4):284–93.
A controlled trial to improve care for seriously ill hospitalized patients. The study to understand prognoses and preferences for outcomes and risks of treatments (SUPPORT). The SUPPORT Principal Investigators. JAMA. 1995; 274(20):1591-8.
Manara AR, Pittman JA, Braddon FE. Reasons for withdrawing treatment in patients receiving intensive care. Anaesthesia. 1998;53(6):523–8.
Moss AH. 'At least we do not feel guilty': Managing conflict with families over dialysis discontinuation. Am J Kidney Dis. 1998;31(5):868–83.
Jecker NS. Knowing when to stop: the limits of medicine. Hastings Cent Rep. 1991;21(3):5–8.
Burns JP, Truog RD. Futility: a concept in evolution. Chest. 2007;132(6):1987–93.
Schneiderman LJ, Jecker NS, Jonsen AR. Medical futility: its meaning and ethical implications. Ann Intern Med. 1990;112(12):949–54.
Jecker NS, Schneiderman LJ. Futility and rationing. Am J Med. 1992;92(2):189–96.
Talmor D, Shapiro N, Greenberg D, et al. When is critical care medicine cost-effective? A systematic review of the cost-effectiveness literature. Crit Care Med. 2006;34(11):2738–47.
Leonhardt D: After the Great Recession. New York Times Magazine, 2009.
Curtis JR, Park DR, Krone MR, Pearlman RA. Use of the medical futility rationale in do-not-attempt-resuscitation orders. JAMA. 1995;273(2):124–8.
Counsell C. Formulating questions and locating primary studies for inclusion in systematic reviews. Ann Intern Med. 1997;127(5):380–7.
O'Brien E, Hendricks D, Cone DC. Field termination of resuscitation: analysis of a newly implemented protocol. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2008;12(1):57–61.
Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann Intern Med. 2009;151(4):264–9. W264.
Cone DC, Bailey ED, Spackman AB. The safety of a field termination-of-resuscitation protocol. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2005;9(3):276–81.
Velmahos GC, Chan L, Chan M, et al. Is there a limit to massive blood transfusion after severe trauma? Arch Surg. 1998;133(9):947–52.
Meesters RC, van der Graaf Y, Vos A, Eikelboom BC. Ruptured aortic aneurysm: early postoperative prediction of mortality using an organ system failure score. Br J Surg. 1994;81(4):512–6.
Dobkin JE, Cutler RE. Use of APACHE II classification to evaluate outcome of patients receiving hemodialysis in an intensive care unit. West J Med. 1988;149(5):547–50.
Tversky A, Kahneman D. The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice. Science. 1981;211(4481):453–8.
Willis CD, Cameron PA, Bernard SA, Fitzgerald M. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation after traumatic cardiac arrest is not always futile. Injury. 2006;37(5):448–54.
Eisenburger P, Havel C, Sterz F, et al. Transport with ongoing cardiopulmonary resuscitation may not be futile. Br J Anaesth. 2008;101(4):518–22.
Huaringa AJ, Leyva FJ, Giralt SA, et al. Outcome of bone marrow transplantation patients requiring mechanical ventilation. Crit Care Med. 2000;28(4):1014–17.
Falcone RE, Herron H, Johnson R, et al. Air medical transport for the trauma patient requiring cardiopulmonary resuscitation: a 10-year experience. Air Med J. 1995;14(4):197–203. discussion 204–195.
Rosemurgy AS, Norris PA, Olson SM, et al. Prehospital traumatic cardiac arrest: the cost of futility. J Trauma. 1993;35(3):468–73.
Stockinger ZT, McSwain NE Jr. Additional evidence in support of withholding or terminating cardiopulmonary resuscitation for trauma patients in the field. J Am Coll Surg. 2004;198(2):227–31.
Cera SM, Mostafa G, Sing RF, et al. Physiologic predictors of survival in post-traumatic arrest. Am Surg. 2003;69(2):140–4.
Lockey D, Crewdson K, Davies G. Traumatic cardiac arrest: who are the survivors? Ann Emerg Med. 2006;48(3):240–4.
Chang RW. Individual outcome prediction models for intensive care units. Lancet. 1989;2(8655):143–6.
Ewer MS, Kish SK, Martin CG, Price KJ, Feeley TW. Characteristics of cardiac arrest in cancer patients as a predictor of survival after cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Cancer. 2001;92(7):1905–12.
Marsden AK, Ng GA, Dalziel K, Cobbe SM. When is it futile for ambulance personnel to initiate cardiopulmonary resuscitation? BMJ. 1995;311(6996):49–51.
Richman PB, Vadeboncoeur TF, Chikani V, Clark L, Bobrow BJ. Independent evaluation of an out-of-hospital termination of resuscitation (TOR) clinical decision rule. Acad Emerg Med. 2008;15(6):517–21.
Sasson C, Hegg AJ, Macy M, et al. Surveillance Group. Prehospital termination of resuscitation in cases of refractory out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. JAMA. 2008;300(12):1432–8.
van der Hoeven JG, Waanders H, Compier EA, van der Weyden PK, Meinders AE. Prolonged resuscitation efforts for cardiac arrest patients who cannot be resuscitated at the scene: who is likely to benefit? Ann Emerg Med. 1993;22(11):1659–63.
van Walraven C, Forster AJ, Stiell IG. Derivation of a clinical decision rule for the discontinuation of in-hospital cardiac arrest resuscitations. Arch Intern Med. 1999;159(2):129–34.
van Walraven C, Forster AJ, Parish DC, et al. Validation of a clinical decision aid to discontinue in-hospital cardiac arrest resuscitations. JAMA. 2001;285(12):1602–6.
Väyrynen T, Kuisma M, Määttä T, Boyd J. Medical futility in asystolic out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2008;52(1):81–7.
Hamel MB, Phillips RS, Davis RB, et al. Outcomes and cost-effectiveness of initiating dialysis and continuing aggressive care in seriously ill hospitalized adults. SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments. Ann Intern Med. 1997;127(3):195–202.
Rodriguez RM, Wang NE, Pearl RG. Prediction of poor outcome of intensive care unit patients admitted from the emergency department. Crit Care Med. 1997;25(11):1801–6.
Teno JM, Murphy D, Lynn J, et al. Prognosis-based futility guidelines: does anyone win? SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatment. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1994;42(11):1202–7.
Azoulay E, Alberti C, Bornstain C, et al. Improved survival in cancer patients requiring mechanical ventilatory support: impact of noninvasive mechanical ventilatory support. Crit Care Med. 2001;29(3):519–25.
Finer NN, Tarin T, Vaucher YE, Barrington K, Bejar R. Intact survival in extremely low birth weight infants after delivery room resuscitation. Pediatrics. 1999;104(4):e40.
Huaringa AJ, Leyva FJ, Giralt SA, et al. Outcome of bone marrow transplantation patients requiring mechanical ventilation. Crit Care Med. 2000;28(4):1014–7.
Swor RA, Jackson RE, Tintinalli JE, Pirrallo RG. Does advanced age matter in outcomes after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in community-dwelling adults? Acad Emerg Med. 2000;7(7):762–8.
Acknowledgement
This work was done with the support of the Clinical and Translational Science Center, Tufts Medical Center. Grant number: NIH/NCRR 1UL1 RR025752
Conflict of Interest
In the last 3 years, Dr. Kent consulted for Eli Lilly and received research funding from Pfizer.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gabbay, E., Calvo-Broce, J., Meyer, K.B. et al. The Empirical Basis for Determinations of Medical Futility. J GEN INTERN MED 25, 1083–1089 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-010-1445-3
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-010-1445-3