Abstract
In several countries, general practitioners conduct post-mortem external examination (PMEE) and certify death in out-of-hospital cases. A possible lack of accuracy has been repeatedly criticised, although data on everyday practice of PMEE on outpatients are scarce. To evaluate medical practitioner’s competence, education and accuracy regarding PMEE, we conducted a fax-survey among 1343 medical doctors in the metropolitan area of Hamburg, Germany. The results indicate considerable shortcomings in up to 63% regarding the inspection of body orifices and hidden areas, palpation of osseous structures, ectropionisation of the eyelids and use of aids. More than 5% of respondents reported to fill in a death certificate without performing a complete PMEE in the majority of cases. While theoretical teaching on PMEE was reported quite frequently (up to 78%), a considerably smaller group received practical training (32% during undergraduate and 13% during postgraduate education). To estimate the effects of training on PMEE, an individual “accuracy score” was calculated (range 1–5). Mean score was 3.63 (SD 0.81), and results differed significantly (p < 0.001) among groups of medical practitioners with or without education on PMEE and was highest among doctors who received practical training (p < 0.005). The results indicate that there are major shortcomings in a relevant portion of PMEE performed on out-of-hospital deaths that might lead to misdiagnosis of non-natural causes of deaths and homicides. Practical pre- and postgraduate education appears to positively impact accuracy and therefore quality of the procedure. Consequently, corresponding practical training should be mandatory during academic studies and ongoing education programs.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Das C (2005) Death certificates in Germany, England, The Netherlands, Belgium and the USA. Eur J Health Law 12:193–211
Saukko P (1983) Die Leichenschau in Skandinavien. Beitr Gerichtl Med 42:339–341
Magrane BP, Gilliand MGF, King DE (1997) Certification of death by family physicians. Am Fam Physician 56:1433–1438
Stevenson R (2008) Death certification practices of forensic physicians within the Strathclyde region of Scotland, UK. J For Med 15:245–249
Myers KA, Eden D (2007) Death duties: workshop on what family physicians are expected to do when patients die. Can Fam Physician 53:1035–1038
Anders S, Fischer-Bruegge D, Fabian M, Raupach T, Petersen-Ewert C, Harendza S (2011) Teaching post-mortem external examination in undergraduate medical education—the formal and the informal curriculum. Forensic Sci Int 210:87–90
Brinkmann B, Banaschak S, Bratzke H, Cremer U, Drese G, Erfurt C, Giebe W, Lang C, Lange E, Peschel O, Philipp KP, Püschel K, Risse M, Tutsch-Bauer E, Vock R, Du Chesne A (1997) Fehlleistungen bei der Leichenschau in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Ergebnisse einer multizentrischen Studie (I). Arch Kriminol 199:1–12
Brinkmann B, Banaschak S, Bratzke H, Cremer U, Drese G, Erfurt C, Giebe W, Lang C, Lange E, Peschel O, Philipp KP, Püschel K, Risse M, Tutsch-Bauer E, Vock R, Du Chesne A (1997) Fehlleistungen bei der Leichenschau in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Ergebnisse einer multizentrischen Studie (II). Arch Kriminol 199:65–74
Vennemann B, Du Chesne A, Brinkmann B (2001) Die Praxis der ärztlichen Leichenschau. Dtsch Med Wschr 126:712–716
Madea B, Dettmeyer R (2003) Ärztliche Leichenschau und Todesbescheinigung. Kompetente Durchführung trotz unterschiedlicher Gesetzgebung der Länder. Dtsch Ärztebl 100:A-3161–A-3179
Rothschild MA (2009) Probleme bei der ärztlichen Leichenschau – Sicht der niedergelassenen Ärzte, der Klinikärzte, der Notärzte und der Polizei. Rechtsmedizin 19:407–412
Gleich S, Schweitze S, Kraus S, Graw M (2015) Ärztliche Leichenschau. Qualität ausgestellter Todesbescheinigungen aus Sicht eines Großstadtgesundheitsamts. Rechtsmedizin 25:523–530
Al Beraiki KH, Schiwy-Bochat KH, Rothschild MA (2011) Homicidial strangulation by victim’s own artificial hair extensions. Int J Legal Med 125:459–461
Zweihoff RF, Püschel K (2009) Herzstillstand und natürliche Todesart. Stattdessen war es Erdrosseln. Rechtsmedizin 19:428–420
Grellner W (2009) Aufdeckung eines verkannten Tötungsdeliktes durch Exhumierung. Arch Kriminol 223:32–60
Trübner K, Kleiber M, Heide S (2012) Der “natürliche” Tod einer Betreuten. Arch Kriminol 229:96–106
Nelson CL, Winston DC (2006) Detection of medical examiner cases from review of cremation requests. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 27:103–105
Schmeling A, Kellinghaus M, Becker JC, Schulz R, Schäfer A, Pfeiffer H (2011) A web-based e-learning programme for training external post-mortem examination in curricular medical education. Int J Legal Med 125:857–861
Davis DA, Mazmanian PE, Fordis M, Van Harrison R, Thorpe KE, Perrier L (2006) Accuracy of physician self-assessment compared with observed measures of competence. JAMA 296:1094–1102
Mandel LS, Goff BA, Lentz GM (2005) Self-assessment of resident surgical skills: is it feasible? Am J Obstet Gynecol 193:1817–1822
Anders S, Pyka K, Mueller T, von Steinbuechel N, Raupach T (2016) Influence of the wording of evaluation items on outcome-based evaluation results for large-group teaching in anatomy, biochemistry and legal medicine. Ann Anat 208:222–227
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schröder, A.S., Wilmes, S., Sehner, S. et al. Post-mortem external examination: competence, education and accuracy of general practitioners in a metropolitan area. Int J Legal Med 131, 1701–1706 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-017-1559-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-017-1559-9